Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Since we can’t get this year’s brackets totally ironed out, why not briefly look ahead to the upcoming Open Division bracket.  Unless amended by the FHSAA Board of Directors, the Open Division will debut in 2026 as a mandatory (not optional) bracket for the top 8 teams in the FHSAA rankings after the regular season.  If the Open Division was in effect this year, these would be the opening round matchups:

  • #8 Bolles @ #1 DeLand
  • #5 Miami NW @ #4 Buchholz
  • #6 Mandarin @ #3 Vero Beach
  • #7 Carrollwood Day @ #2 Cardinal Mooney

Not terrible, but these are some of the teams left out (and their final ranking): Raines (#9); Armwood (#10); Edgewater (#12); Lakeland (#14); C-M (#15); STA (#17).  Once again, relying solely on computer rankings may not achieve the desired goals.   


Posted
4 hours ago, Dr. D said:

Since we can’t get this year’s brackets totally ironed out, why not briefly look ahead to the upcoming Open Division bracket.  Unless amended by the FHSAA Board of Directors, the Open Division will debut in 2026 as a mandatory (not optional) bracket for the top 8 teams in the FHSAA rankings after the regular season.  If the Open Division was in effect this year, these would be the opening round matchups:

 
The Vacation Package for Harry Potter™ Fans
Experience the magic and excitement of an amazing vacation package for Harry Potter™ fans.
ad.doubleclick.net
thumbnail.jpg?domain=ad.doubleclick.net
>
 
 

 

  • #8 Bolles @ #1 DeLand
  • #5 Miami NW @ #4 Buchholz
  • #6 Mandarin @ #3 Vero Beach
  • #7 Carrollwood Day @ #2 Cardinal Mooney

Not terrible, but these are some of the teams left out (and their final ranking): Raines (#9); Armwood (#10); Edgewater (#12); Lakeland (#14); C-M (#15); STA (#17).  Once again, relying solely on computer rankings may not achieve the desired goals.   

I wish that the mandatory open division playoffs were happening this year . . . because if both Lakeland and STA got left out, all hell would break loose and the FHSAA would have to change things fast!   B)

Posted
On 11/7/2025 at 3:43 PM, Perspective said:

I wish that the mandatory open division playoffs were happening this year . . . because if both Lakeland and STA got left out, all hell would break loose and the FHSAA would have to change things fast!   B)

How many of these top 8 win a state title?  The open division is a great idea until you use the FHSAA rankings which suck.  

Posted
On 11/7/2025 at 11:26 AM, Dr. D said:

Since we can’t get this year’s brackets totally ironed out, why not briefly look ahead to the upcoming Open Division bracket.  Unless amended by the FHSAA Board of Directors, the Open Division will debut in 2026 as a mandatory (not optional) bracket for the top 8 teams in the FHSAA rankings after the regular season.  If the Open Division was in effect this year, these would be the opening round matchups:

  • #8 Bolles @ #1 DeLand
  • #5 Miami NW @ #4 Buchholz
  • #6 Mandarin @ #3 Vero Beach
  • #7 Carrollwood Day @ #2 Cardinal Mooney

Not terrible, but these are some of the teams left out (and their final ranking): Raines (#9); Armwood (#10); Edgewater (#12); Lakeland (#14); C-M (#15); STA (#17).  Once again, relying solely on computer rankings may not achieve the desired goals.   

I'm stunned.  The whole purpose was to get STA, Chaminade, AHP, CCC, MNW, Miami Central, Venice, etc. into their own bracket.  The open division does not solve this at all.

Posted
19 hours ago, badbird said:

How many of these top 8 win a state title?  The open division is a great idea until you use the FHSAA rankings which suck.  

I looked back to last year and 4 of the top 8 teams in the end-of-regular-season rankings won state titles -- Venice, C-M, West Boca Raton, and AH-P.  I would put this year's over/under at 2 for state titles out of the current group.  

Posted
14 hours ago, PinellasFB said:

I'm stunned.  The whole purpose was to get STA, Chaminade, AHP, CCC, MNW, Miami Central, Venice, etc. into their own bracket.  The open division does not solve this at all.

It would have if the number of teams scooped up in that bracket was 16 like I believe it should be and they went with straight MaxPrep rankings. 

Posted
4 hours ago, nolebull813 said:

That would make every other bracket the worst in the history of the sport 

Perspective my friend as the OPEN CHAMPION would be declared the only STATE CHAMPION.  However, there are still many good, solid programs out there that could compete for a GOLD, SILVER & BRONZE championship award with fair competition in each and every bracket as most observers would declare what we currently have today is closer to your "Worst in History" declaration.   Less teams would resign themselves to leave the FHSAA as is happening today due to the lack of hope in reaching a desired goal.  But what do I know when disagreeing with the "ALL KNOWING ORACLE OF DELPHI"!

Posted
5 hours ago, Ray Icaza said:

Perspective my friend as the OPEN CHAMPION would be declared the only STATE CHAMPION.  However, there are still many good, solid programs out there that could compete for a GOLD, SILVER & BRONZE championship award with fair competition in each and every bracket as most observers would declare what we currently have today is closer to your "Worst in History" declaration.   Less teams would resign themselves to leave the FHSAA as is happening today due to the lack of hope in reaching a desired goal.  But what do I know when disagreeing with the "ALL KNOWING ORACLE OF DELPHI"!

So if that was the case then that would be ok. But that would never happen. If they just called the open winner the “state champion” and the rest of the winners the “Gold bracket champ”, “silver bracket champ” etc etc

Only the FHSAA can take something that is the worst in history and make it worse!

  • 1 month later...
Posted
On 11/7/2025 at 11:26 AM, Dr. D said:

Since we can’t get this year’s brackets totally ironed out, why not briefly look ahead to the upcoming Open Division bracket.  Unless amended by the FHSAA Board of Directors, the Open Division will debut in 2026 as a mandatory (not optional) bracket for the top 8 teams in the FHSAA rankings after the regular season.  If the Open Division was in effect this year, these would be the opening round matchups:

  • #8 Bolles @ #1 DeLand
  • #5 Miami NW @ #4 Buchholz
  • #6 Mandarin @ #3 Vero Beach
  • #7 Carrollwood Day @ #2 Cardinal Mooney

Not terrible, but these are some of the teams left out (and their final ranking): Raines (#9); Armwood (#10); Edgewater (#12); Lakeland (#14); C-M (#15); STA (#17).  Once again, relying solely on computer rankings may not achieve the desired goals.   

This is not going well.  The rankings are a joke.  FHSAA you must adjust your mystical rankings that you use and don't tell anyone how you get it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...


  • Posts

    • I’ve been to 15 Finals.  This year’s games were the best I’ve ever attended.  For what it’s worth, here are my thoughts.  I sat on the the Press Box/Suites side for every game.   Elevate Everyday Play Elevated play essentials that make space for what matters. Our pieces look as...   > 1A - The Chaminade fans I interacted with were very overconfident.  I sat near one whose stepson was the starting center.  I told him I thought Cardinal Newman would keep the game close until halftime and then Chaminade would run away with it.    He looked at me like I was crazy then proceeded telling me how superior Chaminade was.  After Cardinal Newman scored the first touchdown I didn’t even look at him.  He then proceeded to get up and found a cluster of Chaminade fans to sit with.     Elevate Everyday Play Elevated play essentials that make space for what matters. Our pieces look as...   >   Elevate Everyday Play Elevated play essentials that make space for what matters. Our pieces look as...   > When the game ended many of the Chaminade fans just sat and stared into space.  Not looking at each other.  Not saying anything. 2A - I took enjoyment watching a team from the city of Sarasota where I grew up from the age of 10.  Had seen both teams play this year so I thought I had a good gauge on this game.  I mistakenly thought this would be a closer game.  I was amazed how much Mooney dominated the lines of scrimmage. 3A - The big story this season for Northwestern was the replacement at QB of last year’s starter, Leon Strawder, with a sophomore transfer from Ransom Everglades. The Bulls new QB, Neumann Lawrence, was brought over to Northwestern by Teddy Bridgewater himself (at least that was what I was told).  I saw this new QB play twice for the Bulls and he was phenomenal.  Friday night Raines put a lot of pressure on him so he struggled most of the game. I began keeping my eye on Raines especially during the playoffs. I told some that Raines would not beat Northwestern but you would be surprised how close Raines’ talent level was to the Bulls.  The responses were not positive.  I stayed to watch the Vikings celebration.  I’m really happy for them. 4A - This game did go as I thought.  I did not see Jones play this year but I’m very familiar with the program.  I saw AHP play Archbishop McCarthy in the Regional Final.  Despite making early mistakes and taking McCarthy’s best shot the Patriots prevailed.  That night I saw an AHP that was patient, confident and did not get rattled.   5A - Nothing to say except boring. 6A - The clock struck midnight for a young and dangerous West Broward team.  West Boca Raton was dominant and West Broward looked like they had completely run out of that mojo that got them to the finals. 7A - Vero Beach fans must have outnumbered Lake Mary fans 4 to 1.  Many times during the game I heard different people say it’s going to be a long ride home if we don’t win. During the game I was in a group text that Laz was in.  If you don’t know already Laz is a big Lake Mary fan.  During the game we had to talk him off the ledge when Vero was scoring at will.  A few times Laz texted that the game was over and he was going to turn it off.  He hung in there long enough to see his beloved Rams pull off the play of the year and win their first state title.  Congratulations Laz! More random thoughts: * It was obvious Chaminade and Northwestern came into their games emotionally not ready.  Pretty sure they did not fully respect their opponents. * Would the Bulls have won with Strawder at QB?  IMO, probably.   * At the beginning of the season QB Darryon Jones was on Chaminade’s roster.  Not sure why Darryon transferred out to Venice.  He played very well for Venice.  Would the Lions have beat Cardinal Newman with him at the helm?  IMO, probably. * Please give Aquinas a quality opponent next year. * I see that Mike E left the 7A game early because of a little rain.  Just kidding, I stayed but I was soaked.  Truth be told I briefly considered leaving at about the same time Mike left in the 4th quarter.
    • Is there any possibility that you would be willing to be more specific? 
    • Could better coaching decisions have put the game away earlier? 
    • What are you talking about? Are you claiming that the game officials made up the penalties? 
  • Who's Online (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...