Broward vs Dade Matchups-Who Would Win?

[OldSchoolLion]

So far this season, we have seen 7 matchups of the better teams from Broward vs the better teams from Miami-Dade.  Bolded below are the winners of those games.  BTW and Chaminade face off shortly in what will be an eighth matchup.  Imagine if we have had the 7 matchups further below scheduled this year.  That would be a total of 15 Broward vs Dade games.  Who would come out on top?  In other words, who would win more of the 15 games, Broward or Dade?      

Central vs St Thomas Aquinas   

Northwestern vs Miramar  

Carol City vs AHP

Northwestern vs AHP

Booker T Washington vs Dillard

Jackson vs Hallandale

Jackson vs Cardinal Gibbons

Booker T Washington vs Chaminade-Madonna

 

Hypothetical matchups:

Carol City vs St Thomas Aquinas

Central vs Deerfield Beach

South Dade vs Deerfield Beach

Columbus vs University School

Columbus vs Cardinal Gibbons

Southridge vs Western

Palmetto vs McArthur

 

 

[OldSchoolLion]

IMO Broward has never been that close to Dade throughout the history of the FHSAA, except possibly in the early 90's.

In the early 90's, STA, Cardinal Gibbons, Dillard, Ely and Deerfield Beach were very good-to-excellent.  Today, there is STA, AHP, Cardinal Gibbons, Chaminade, and Deerfield Beach.  So, at its very best, Broward County had 5 contenders in any one year.  That's been the norm in Miami-Dade.  

...if one wants to compare FHSAA state titles.....Broward County has 24 and Dade County has 37.  And the Broward numbers are skewed because so many of those titles(10) were won by STA, whereas Miami-Dade has 13 different teams that have won state titles.  

[gatormike20]

Broward Titles

STA -10

AHP - 4

Chaminade -3

Dillard-2

Ely- 1

Miramar-1

Hills -1

Flanagan -1 

Lion, this in only 23, who did I miss ?

[OldSchoolLion]

3 hours ago, gatormike20 said:

Broward Titles

STA -10

AHP - 4

Chaminade -3

Dillard-2

Ely- 1

Miramar-1

Hills -1

Flanagan -1 

Lion, this in only 23, who did I miss ?

1990 Class A Westminster

[Miamidade92]

On 10/6/2018 at 12:23 PM, OldSchoolLion said:

So far this season, we have seen 7 matchups of the better teams from Broward vs the better teams from Miami-Dade.  Bolded below are the winners of those games.  BTW and Chaminade face off shortly in what will be an eighth matchup.  Imagine if we have had the 7 matchups further below scheduled this year.  That would be a total of 15 Broward vs Dade games.  Who would come out on top?  In other words, who would win more of the 15 games, Broward or Dade?      

Central vs St Thomas Aquinas   

Northwestern vs Miramar  

Carol City vs AHP

Northwestern vs AHP

Booker T Washington vs Dillard

Jackson vs Hallandale

Jackson vs Cardinal Gibbons

Booker T Washington vs Chaminade-Madonna

 

Hypothetical matchups:

Carol City vs St Thomas Aquinas

Central vs Deerfield Beach

South Dade vs Deerfield Beach

Columbus vs University School

Columbus vs Cardinal Gibbons

Southridge vs Western

Palmetto vs McArthur