Question for Josh

[badbird]

how does Chaminade stay ranked #7 when they lost to #22 this week?  Was somebody hurt?  Is columbiafan doing your rankings?

[DisabledAccount]

Just now, badbird said:

how does Chaminade stay ranked #7 when they lost to #22 this week?  Was somebody hurt?  Is columbiafan doing your rankings?

Shut up LMAO

 

I actually dropped Chaminade to low 20s in my poll 

[badbird]

5 minutes ago, ColumbiaHighFan2017class said:

Shut up LMAO

 

I actually dropped Chaminade to low 20s in my poll 

I can’t ask a question?  They lost and only fell one spot.  I need to know why because they are a pick em game and I know nothing about them other than they acquire players like the Yankees acquire  free agents

[DisabledAccount]

Just now, badbird said:

I can’t ask a question?  They lost and only fell one spot.  I need to know why because they are a pick em game and I know nothing about them other than they acquire players like the Yankees acquire  free agents

Sure you can

 

I was giving that response because of that little comment about me doing the rankings even though I have a much different placement in my rankings for Chaminade lol

[DisabledAccount]

2 minutes ago, badbird said:

I can’t ask a question?  They lost and only fell one spot.  I need to know why because they are a pick em game and I know nothing about them other than they acquire players like the Yankees acquire  free agents

They have some talent but are not as strong overall as the team last year if it helps

 

I actually picked Atlantic to beat Chaminade

[badbird]

1 minute ago, ColumbiaHighFan2017class said:

Sure you can

 

I was giving that response because of that little comment about me doing the rankings even though I have a much different placement in my rankings for Chaminade lol

I know silly.  

[badbird]

1 minute ago, ColumbiaHighFan2017class said:

They have some talent but are not as strong overall as the team last year if it helps

 

I actually picked Atlantic to beat Chaminade

Or did you pick them because they play Columbia.  I got to figure this out. 

[DisabledAccount]

Just now, badbird said:

Or did you pick them because they play Columbia.  I got to figure this out. 

3 reasons for my pick

 

1 Atlantic is a larger school and should have depth advantage

 

2 Chaminade isn't as strong as team from last year

 

3 Atlantic may very well be strongest team in PBC and from what I saw of them they looked pretty damn good

[badbird]

Just now, ColumbiaHighFan2017class said:

3 reasons for my pick

 

1 Atlantic is a larger school and should have depth advantage

 

2 Chaminade isn't as strong as team from last year

 

3 Atlantic may very well be strongest team in PBC and from what I saw of them they looked pretty damn good

I picked them too but have no idea why.  

[Joshua Wilson]

16 hours ago, badbird said:

how does Chaminade stay ranked #7 when they lost to #22 this week?  Was somebody hurt?  Is columbiafan doing your rankings?

The reason I didn't drop them that much is because after looking at everything, it was very evident the officials played a significant role in the outcome of the game. I am not 100% sold on Carol City. If they lose to Atlantic that is certainly going to drop them further, but I can't fully justify a full drop after something that was not decided on the field. Carol City is struggling up and down and really I feel Chaminade-Madonna is the better team still. 

[Perspective]

5 minutes ago, Joshua Wilson said:

The reason I didn't drop them that much is because after looking at everything, it was very evident the officials played a significant role in the outcome of the game. I am not 100% sold on Carol City. If they lose to Atlantic that is certainly going to drop them further, but I can't fully justify a full drop after something that was not decided on the field. Carol City is struggling up and down and really I feel Chaminade-Madonna is the better team still. 

Interesting.  I'd be interested to hear you elaborate on how the officials played a significant role in the outcome of the game.  

Admittedly, I don't have a dog in the fight, but I like a good conspiracy theory as much as the next guy.  

[Joshua Wilson]

1 hour ago, Perspective said:

Interesting.  I'd be interested to hear you elaborate on how the officials played a significant role in the outcome of the game.  

Admittedly, I don't have a dog in the fight, but I like a good conspiracy theory as much as the next guy.  

Apparently, the video showed Chaminade-Madonna making a critical conversion on 4th down to keep their drive alive to potentially score points and the officials ruled that they didn't have enough. It is controversial and that is why I didn't want to knee jerk on moving them down many spots because of that and being a 1-point game. 

[badbird]

2 hours ago, Joshua Wilson said:

The reason I didn't drop them that much is because after looking at everything, it was very evident the officials played a significant role in the outcome of the game. I am not 100% sold on Carol City. If they lose to Atlantic that is certainly going to drop them further, but I can't fully justify a full drop after something that was not decided on the field. Carol City is struggling up and down and really I feel Chaminade-Madonna is the better team still. 

Thanks for answering.  I didn’t see the game or hear what happened.  Sounds like  Chaminade wasn’t a lock to win even if they didn’t get hosed on a spot.  They can redeem themself this week.