Jump to content
  1. The Huddle

    1. The Huddle

      The place to discuss football at all levels: high school, college and professional.

      120.7k
      posts
  2. Flag Football Huddle

    1. Flag Football Huddle

      A forum for the state's fastest-growing high school sport... Girls Flag Football

      2
      posts
  3. Off Topic

    1. Off Topic Board

      All non-football talk is to be reserved for this board.

      1.5k
      posts

Announcements

  • Posts

    • Although you raise valid points, I'm not sure what they have to do with the issue that was raised by WhatUpDoc, i.e., whether private schools can or cannot recruit under existing FHSAA rules.  I can't tell you how many times I've heard someone (a parent, a fan, a player, a forum poster or even a high school football coach) say something to the effect that "well, that's because private schools are allowed to recruit." No, they are not.   Also, I'm curious about your school choice comment.  It has always been my understanding that if a school is at or over capacity, it cannot accept out-of-district students.  Conversely, if the school is under capacity, it has no choice but to allow an out-of-district student to attend.   If that is the case (and perhaps that's just the way it's done in Hillsborough County), then there is no way for a public school to show favoritism towards a football player over a tuba player.   Am I missing something? Finally, while I'm sure it happens, FHSAA Bylaws state as follows:  "9.9.4.6 Must Not be Used to Recruit. NIL activities shall not be used to pressure, urge, or entice a student-athlete to attend a school for the purpose of participating in interscholastic athletics. The NIL agreement shall not be used as a guise for athletic recruiting (reference Policies 36 and 37)."    Moreover, neither public nor private schools can offer NIL deals.  "No school employee, athletic department staff member, or representative of a school’s athletic interests as defined in Bylaw 1.4.17 (a-e), may form, direct, offer, provide, or otherwise engage in any activity outlined in FHSAA Bylaw 9.9."  So, if Big Dave, from Big Dave's Used Cars, is the president of the booster club, they are not allowed to offer NIL deals to kids going to "his" school.   That said, I understand there is a big difference between the world as outlined in the FHSAA rules and the real world . . . for better or for worse.    
    • @gbrown977 WB, CM, Columbus, STA   @nolebull813 West Boca, Chaminade, Columbus, STA
    • Are public schools allowed to recruit?  No, not according to FHSAA rules. Do public schools recruit? Of course they do.   Are public schools allowed to offer scholarships to students based on their athletic ability?  No, but they can offer NIL deals. Do public schools provide NIL deals to students based on their athletic ability?  Of course they do.   Do public schools favor stellar athletes (especially football) over other students who want to participate in a specific band, theater, or STEM program when it comes to school choice? Of course they do.    School Choice has leveled the playing field when it comes to the recruiting aspect between public and private. In my opinion, schools should not be separated based on public and private but instead should be based on competitive ability. North Port and Lehigh should not be anywhere near a Venice when it comes to districts. There are numerous other examples of this we could use throughout the state as well. 
    • Well, now that the can is open . . . Are private schools allowed to recruit?  No, not according to FHSAA rules. Do private schools recruit?  Of course they do.   Are private schools allowed to offer scholarships to students based on their athletic ability?  No, not according to FHSAA rules.  Do private schools provide scholarships to students based on their athletic ability?  Of course they do.   Does the FHSAA turn a blind eye to private school recruiting?  It sure seems that way.   But, recall, the FHSAA basically did away with their enforcement department and now rely on (1) schools self-reporting violations or (2) someone turning in a school for a violation and the FHSAA then sending out a notification to the school in hopes that the school will recognize their wrongdoing and formally self-report the violation.   My point is simple:  private schools are in the same boat as public schools when it comes to the FHSAA rules regarding recruiting:  neither is allowed to do it.  But the structure of private schools allows them to get away with it easier.  The smart private schools fly under the radar because they do the lion's share of their "recruiting" before the kids enter the ninth grade in hopes the kids pan out . . . and if they don't, well, the school can simply decide not to renew the scholarship, knowing the kids' families won't be able to afford to send their kids to the school without it. Harsh, but true.  
    • While this may be true, it would also be foolhardy to believe parents are not the driving force of many of these transfers. Youth sports, once performed primarily at the recreational level, has moved almost exclusively to club and travel teams. This includes football. Parents of good football players have been "shopping" their kids for many years, rotating from team to team, attempting to find the best situation. By the time these kids reach high, families have already been conditioned for years to treat sticking around as a mistake and bouncing from team to team as the smart play. So, is there recruiting from school to player? Sure. But more often than not, it is the parents who are initiating the contact and shopping their kids around first.
×
×
  • Create New...