Jump to content

Perspective

Members
  • Posts

    2,134
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    165

Posts posted by Perspective

  1. 1 hour ago, DarterBlue2 said:

    I am in agreement with you. But it probably would never happen as it would affect football recruiting negatively vis a viz compared with other states to some degree, especially for the seniors that don't have a bunch of offers already approaching February (National signing day). 

    That is one of the downsides, but it could possibly be offset by the fact that college coaches (from teams whose seasons have ended or even from teams that are in bowl games) could actually attend the high school games without having to leave at the end of the first quarter to rush back for their own Saturday game.  They could even attend practices.  Same with basketball:  coaches could attend more games because their season will not have started yet. 

    The other reason why some people wouldn't like it is because it would likely eliminate OOS games and, thus, the opportunity to compete for a mythical national championship. 

    Not to get all melodramatic, but last week a kid from Tampa died during summer workouts.  I just saw on Twitter that the same thing just happened to another a 15-year kid in Louisiana.  Without opening up a political debate, the science behind global warming may ultimately lead the folks in charge of high school and youth sports to look more closely at when certain outdoor activities are taking place. 

  2. I like the idea of August and September games having a later start time (8:00, 8:30).  Many times, that's about what time the games start anyway because of weather delays. 

    But (and not to completely change the subject of this thread), I'm also the guy who thinks Florida ought to go rogue and switch football and basketball seasons . . .  play the indoor game when it's hot and stormy outside and then play the outdoor game when the weather in Florida is just right for football.   But, I'll save more on that for a later date. 

  3. Looks like Vanguard is the top team, with Columbia and Steinbrenner battling it out for bridesmaid honors.  A lot of north/central Florida teams . . . not exactly a "statewide" tournament (based on teams participating).  

    What's the scoring system?  I see a few odd 7 on 7 scores.  I'm guessing traditional scoring with 3 points for an INT?

  4. 31 minutes ago, Big Ray said:

    The FHSAA needs to copy what GA is doing!

    But you can learn so much more useless information (that will no doubt change over the next two months) and waste so much more time if you just go to MaxPreps and start randomly clicking on various teams and their schedules.   B)

  5. On 6/8/2019 at 11:52 AM, skyway said:

    It appears Lakeland will be receiving several big-name transfers and several more very good HS players. If it remains this way (it isn't unheard of for kids to transfer and then head back to where they came from like Cleveland Reed a few years ago), they will be back to face STA again barring significant injuries. Lake Wales QB Chayil Garnett, 3* Auburn commit; WR Arian Smith, 4* WR and arguably the fastest player in the state; 4* CB Kendall Dennis and a few more starters from elsewhere including a couple of big lineman. This has been posted on multiple social media outlets where the players themselves are tagged, as well as on 247sports' player database. There is a Twitter post on an anonymous account mentioning other big names, but a couple of those players replied that they were not transferring.

     

    OK, I give up.  I was trying to post a screenshot I took last night of a Twitter post from on the Tampa Bay Times sports reporters and I just can't seem to figure out how to do it (file size always too big).  In any event, the original tweet came from a 10K.sam and it reads:  "Dear Lakeland high school can y'all stop calling my people I am not going to Lakeland i am loyal to my school lake Gibson @LHSDreadnaughts"

    Interesting. 

  6. 19 hours ago, nolebull813 said:

    I proudly called this years ago on the national board that once the new rule is implemented basically letting public schools play by the rules as the privates Lakeland will be back to beating STAs ass. 

    You cant call yourself a true competitive organization and have teams not playing by the same rules. When STA would have double digit transfers from Miami to West Palm no one batted an eye. But when some local Polk County stud wanted to play for the best coach in state history everyone got up in arms. 

    Now every team can acquire talent how they see fit, and everyone can play under the same rules. 

     

    The problem is that not every school plays by the same rules, at least not in Hillsborough County.   In theory, any family can move into a particular school's district and then be able to attend that school.  Also, that same family can stay right where they are and their kid still has the right/ability to attend any other school in the district/county, with one major caveat:  the school cannot be at or above capacity.  So, a school in a less densely populated part of the County with a mediocre academic reputation/ranking, that is not at capacity, can accommodate an unlimited number of transferring students.  Whereas a school in a more populated area with a strong academic reputation/ranking, that has been over capacity for years, can only accommodate a transfer if that kid's family moves into the district.  And, of course, private schools can do whatever the heck they want to and, thus, can accommodate any kid they want to whenever they want to regardless of where the family lives. 

    Free agency doesn't work unless all schools are playing on the same, level playing field and that simply isn't the case.  My guess is that Lakeland, for example, would see far fewer transfers if kids who want to transfer into Lakeland actually had to move into the Lakeland district.   That's not a knock on Lakeland; it's just a reminder that not all public schools are in the same 'boat.'  That assumption is based on some quick research that indicates that Lakeland's student population is well below capacity.   If I'm wrong on that, please correct me with the right info. 

  7. One more thing worth noting:  I can't find a website devoted to the award, but several sites make mention that the "Guy Toph Award has been presented to senior football players who excel on the field and in the classroom."   So, apparently, there is an academic element involved that might cause/prompt some folks to give the nod to one player over another player that seemingly has a tad more talent. 

  8. 17 hours ago, gatorman-uf said:

    Robert Marve
    Aaron Murray
    Stephen Garcia

    are 3 of my guesses

    Yes on Marve; no on Murray and Garcia.  

    Here's a list of the winners since 1990 (the award dates back to 1939):

    2018: Braxton Plunk, Plant City

    2017:  Michael Penix, Tampa Bay Tech

    2016: Malik Davis, Jesuit

    2015: Markese Hargrove, Plant City

    2014: Ray Ray McCloud III, Sickles

    2013: Deiondre Porter, Jefferson

    2012: Vernon Hargreaves, Wharton

    2011: Nelson Agholor, Berkeley Prep

    2010: Quentin Williams, Jefferson

    2009: C.J. Bennett, Alonso

    2008: Dontae Aycock, Chamberlain

    2007: Derek Winter, Plant

    2006: Robert Marve, Plant

    2005: Marcello Trigg, Robinson

    2004: Kalvin Bailey, Armwood

    2003: John Forbes, Alonso

    2002: Andre Caldwell, Jefferson

    2001: Eddie Lee Ivery Jr., Chamberlain

    2000: Lydell Ross, Gaither

    1999: Fred Reid, King

    1998: Gary Godsey, Jesuit

    1997: Mike Pearson, Armwood

    1996: Kenny Kelly, Tampa Catholic

    1995: Derrick Edmonds, Hillsborough

    1994: Keith Newman, Jefferson

    1993: Cliff Dell, King

    1992: Brett Zinober, Berkeley Prep

    1991: Brian Adcock, Chamberlain

    1990: Gary Moore, East Bay

  9. I think the simple answer is this:  if the kid transfers to another school that is a member of the FHSAA, the suspension will follow him and he'll miss the first six games.   If he transfers to a school that is not a member of the FHSAA, he can play right away. 

    That said, six games for a 'sideline altercation' seems pretty steep to me.  Were others involved?  Was the punishment consistent?  First time offense for the kid?  Any extenuating circumstances?  Has an appeal been taken?  Film available? 

  10. 28 minutes ago, Proseteye said:

    Well, let's see. He's an experienced coach and he probably knows that teams always get more players over the summer and  it's just a matter of mathematics. More students registering more players on the team. Looking at some good talent is more of a hope than an affirmation. But, then again you're trying to insinuate an ulterior motive aren't you now? If that were the case why did the Celtics go 5-5 last season? ;)

    Ok, let's get a couple of things straight.  

    First, I have no idea why the team went 5-5 last year.  Unless I look it up on MaxPreps, I seriously doubt I could name a single one of their opponents from last season or this season.  

    Second, I'm not trying to insinuate anything, much less an ulterior motive.  I was simply asking a question based on my understanding that high school football coaches (or any 'representatives of a school’s athletic interests' for that matter) are prohibited from talking with prospective students about playing football until the students are registered -- regardless of whether the school is public or private.  

    If you had said something along the lines of "based on prior years, 10-15 new kids will show up over the summer and be playing on the football team by the time of the KOC," I wouldn't have said a word.  Or, if you had said something along the lines of "Rumor has it that 10-15 new kids will be joining the team over the summer," again, I wouldn't have asked the question that I did.   But, when you start your post out with "According to coach," and then follow it with "he's looking at some good talent joining the team," well, that doesn't leave much to the imagination, now does it?  I'll just assume that the coach is very optimistic and was just doing some out-loud, wishful thinking. 

     

×
×
  • Create New...