I have never seen a schedule that said “VS” Venice implying the game against them was at home 

Venice doesn’t even have buses. Lol.

And I don't even need to go back and look to know where that game will be played. 

Thank you for prompting me to do further research.  Windermere's situation in 2017 is too difficult to research, although your facts are accurate.  Innovation applied for and received an exemption to the 3-year waiting period per the exemptions provided in Bylaws 3.4.1.1.4 & 3.4.1.2.4 -- A newly opening school created by the consolidation or division of the student populations of existing member schools is exempt from the application and provisional periods if a) the new school is governed by the same Board as the existing member schools; and b) the new school meets all other qualifications and conditions of membership.  This exemption allowed Innovation to compete in FHSAA championship series/competition in the 2024-25 year, as the girls' soccer team did (although the football team elected to compete as an independent).  This exemption could possibly apply to PSL Legacy and any other newly opening schools which meet the above criteria.  Sorry for any confusion I may have created.       

They also play Venice SHEESH!!!!