It's flawed because the system isn't doing what it claimed to do
Going further back into the past only deludes the product even more. The fhsaa thought moving away from metro suburban and returning to student enrollment as the only measure of classifications did exactly what i said it would do and look at the playoff results last week if you don't believe me. Pretty sure the average margin of victory was over 30 points for the entire state of Florida
Seeding should absolutely be earned we just need a better formula for it
Wrong, we are the #3 SEED in our Region while South Lake is the #2 SEED. Seeding by the FHSAA is extremely flawed as almost everyone on this forum agrees. That determines home field advantage and your earlier point of a lousy team hosting if you alternate every year is moot if you followed Perspectives view which I agree with is that for the opening round games the DISTRICT CHAMP should host. That will make that possibility minimal. Yes, I would like transparency, but in the end if I could see how they arrived at their mistakes it wouldn't make me feel any better.