Leaderboard

Region 4: BTW, Cardinal Gibbons, Guliver Prep, Carol City, Miami Pace, Univ school(?), Calvary Chapel.

I have to agree..... You have some many former state champions in one region. It will be a war whoever come that region in the Semifinals for us (Glades Central). If we make it of course. We play three of those teams this year (Booker T, Carol City, and Miami Pace)

Lots of discussion on the transfer situation, mostly focusing on Jax area and South Florida where you have large populations in confined area. However, little mention of Dreadnaughts yet coaches in Polk know they steal players to supplement their roster every year. They did it before the rule change and they do it now. Their coach is held in high esteem and no doubt he knows what is going on whether legal or not; just turns a blind eye to it. That is the model they have used to maintain their level of "Excellence"? No matter who does it be it public or private, one cannot deny it is an unfair advantage and as was pointed out by someone in earlier discussions they helped change the rules so they could keep doing it. Most of us are very competitive in nature and want to win terribly, but don't believe in cheating to do it. It just cheapens the accomplishment.

Sure, some of that occurs. But having effective open enrollment subject to capacity makes it extremely difficult to police. Therefore, it is easy to get away with. Over the past 25 years which is about the length of time I have watched area football, the concentration of talent has exploded as rule changes made it easy to go wherever one wished. Look, to me there are legitimate reasons for kids to attend school out of zone. Three that come readily to mind are: 1. Attendance at a Magnet program related to the kid's career interests; 2. In a situation where a kid has already completed at least 2 years of high school when a new school opens up. In this situation, I feel he/she should be allowed to complete high school where they started. 3. A situation where upper level courses are not readily available to a student that that demonstrates the academic capacity to do them. A fourth situation that relates directly to athletics that I would consider legitimate, is if the zoned school does not offer the sport that the student wants to participate in. Aside from the above, I don't believe that kids should be allowed to transfer willy nilly. Athletics in general would fall into the illegitimate category unless the family actually moved into the other school zone.

Hands down the best region

Under current enacted state regulations, you are allowed to go to any public high school of your choice with the only caveats being that if it is not your zoned school it must not be at capacity and you must provide your own transportation. When this went into effect, the FHSAA essentially gave up on trying to police transfers (not that there were doing a stellar job prior to the change). So, until the legislature goes in a different direction, we are stuck with what we have got. In densely populated areas, this basically means that the great majority of talent will tend to congregate at a handful of schools.