Week 10 South Florida “Top 15”

[THIS_IS_DILLARD]

#1. Chaminade

#2. Miami Norland

#3. St Thomas Aquinas 

#4. Homestead 

#5. Miami Central 

#6. Booker T Washington 

#7. American Heritage

#8. Columbus

#9. Palmetto

#10. Cardinal Gibbons 

#11. Coconut Creek

#12. Western 

#13. Dillard 

#14.Monarch

#15. Miramar

 

Outside Looking in- Plantation, South Broward, Archbishop McCarthy, Blanche Ely.

 

@DarterBlue2 @Jullian @VeniceIndianFan

[DarterBlue2]

I agree with the placing of the first 9. I think Gibbons may be too high. I also think Monarch may be a little too low.  But, overall, the ranking of the bottom 4 on the list could be debated in the context of reasonable people having different opinions all of which have some merit.

I think the first 2 on the list are in the first tier; 3-7 are in a second tier; 8-9 and 11, are in a third tier; and the rest in a fourth tier. A case could be made for Ely cracking the top 15, but I don't have an issue excluding them.  

[nolebull813]

Western took care of Miramar in a defensive slug fest 

[THIS_IS_DILLARD]

46 minutes ago, nolebull813 said:

Western took care of Miramar in a defensive slug fest 

That they did. It was a great game. 

[THIS_IS_DILLARD]

46 minutes ago, nolebull813 said:

Western took care of Miramar in a defensive slug fest 

Between two solid programs 

[THIS_IS_DILLARD]

10 hours ago, DarterBlue2 said:

I agree with the placing of the first 9. I think Gibbons may be too high. I also think Monarch may be a little too low.  But, overall, the ranking of the bottom 4 on the list could be debated in the context of reasonable people having different opinions all of which have some merit.

I think the first 2 on the list are in the first tier; 3-7 are in a second tier; 8-9 and 11, are in a third tier; and the rest in a fourth tier. A case could be made for Ely cracking the top 15, but I don't have an issue excluding them.  

Who would you place monarch over ? 
 

& as for ely their 7-1 record is highly deceiving if you ask me. I saw the tigers 3x this year. 1st time blown out by norland, 2nd time blown out by creek.

this past Saturday down 21-6 to a horrible piper team only to escape 33-26.

[DarterBlue2]

22 minutes ago, THIS_IS_DILLARD said:

Who would you place monarch over ? 
 

& as for ely their 7-1 record is highly deceiving if you ask me. I saw the tigers 3x this year. 1st time blown out by norland, 2nd time blown out by creek.

this past Saturday down 21-6 to a horrible piper team only to escape 33-26.

I believe Dillard, Monarch and Cardinal Gibbons based on the way each is playing right now, are about all equal. 

[Jullian]

I’d still put Central at 3. Aquinas on the road this week wasn’t dominant. Would Central beat Monarch by more? Yes. 
I like Gibbons at 10! Everyone beneath them I believe they’d beat or have already. (Creek?). 
Saw Heritage vs Naples. Their D was wore out by the 4th qtr.Had a 31-3 halftime lead. Their passing game was better than average, but that won’t fly in the state semi’s. Their smallest lines ever(DL & OL), but fast. Special teams good. Wouldn’t beat Norland or Central. 
Dillard has a chance to jump up a bit, or a lot this Friday. 

[THIS_IS_DILLARD]

4 hours ago, Jullian said:

I’d still put Central at 3. Aquinas on the road this week wasn’t dominant. Would Central beat Monarch by more? Yes. 
I like Gibbons at 10! Everyone beneath them I believe they’d beat or have already. (Creek?). 
Saw Heritage vs Naples. Their D was wore out by the 4th qtr.Had a 31-3 halftime lead. Their passing game was better than average, but that won’t fly in the state semi’s. Their smallest lines ever(DL & OL), but fast. Special teams good. Wouldn’t beat Norland or Central. 
Dillard has a chance to jump up a bit, or a lot this Friday. 

Facts bro. But if Dillard wants to be respected as a continued solid program they have to put away teams they shouldn’t struggle with. Continuing tonight. 
 

not so good teams would make this game more difficult then it needs to be.