Quantcast
Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
SportsNut25

FNF Magazine State Preseason Rankings

By SportsNut25, in The Huddle

Recommended Posts

ColumbiaHighFan2017class    2,342

ColumbiaHighFan2017class
Posted
31 minutes ago, SportsNut25 said:

Your thoughts? 

  1. STA
  2. Northwestern
  3. Cocoa
  4. AHP
  5. Carol City
  6. Lake Gibson
  7. MIA Central
  8. Jax TCA
  9. Dwyer
  10. Armwood
  11. Southridge
  12. Lakeland
  13. Venice
  14. Plant
  15. Bartram 
  16. Jones
  17. Navarre
  18. Deerfield 
  19. Gables
  20. Gibbons
  21. Lee
  22. Naples
  23. Leon
  24. Moore

Leon?

Bartram? 

Dwyer? 

Navaree?

 

 

Smh really blew that one but i can't wait to post mine in 5 days,  i think my list is by far best when it comes to Florida 

Just A Coach reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

MC Rockets    253

MC Rockets
Posted
2 hours ago, SportsNut25 said:

Your thoughts? 

  1. STA
  2. Northwestern
  3. Cocoa
  4. AHP
  5. Carol City
  6. Lake Gibson
  7. MIA Central
  8. Jax TCA
  9. Dwyer
  10. Armwood
  11. Southridge
  12. Lakeland
  13. Venice
  14. Plant
  15. Bartram 
  16. Jones
  17. Navarre
  18. Deerfield 
  19. Gables
  20. Gibbons
  21. Mainland
  22. Lee
  23. Naples
  24. Leon
  25. Moore

No Booker T Washington? 

This poll has always been suspect. 

KeemD321 and Zoe Boy reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

DarterBlue2    1,729

DarterBlue2
Posted
5 hours ago, SportsNut25 said:

Your thoughts? 

  1. STA
  2. Northwestern
  3. Cocoa
  4. AHP
  5. Carol City
  6. Lake Gibson
  7. MIA Central
  8. Jax TCA
  9. Dwyer
  10. Armwood
  11. Southridge
  12. Lakeland
  13. Venice
  14. Plant
  15. Bartram 
  16. Jones
  17. Navarre
  18. Deerfield 
  19. Gables
  20. Gibbons
  21. Mainland
  22. Lee
  23. Naples
  24. Leon
  25. Moore

Is Moore Bishop Moore? Unless they have a ton of transfers for the new year, they are not top 25. Or if they are, Osceola is top 10. In the spring game they clearly dominated them. There are other Orlando area teams that should be ahead of a number of the above schools. However, I will let the first few weeks of the season play out before I comment further. 

KeemD321, 954gator, Zoe Boy and 1 other reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Joshua Wilson    684

Joshua Wilson
Posted

When the fact I see Leon on this list, I know this list is totally suspect. Leon has proven nothing to be Top 25. New coach and they are instantly Top 25?  Seriously, I want to know who put this list together. SMH. Also Northwestern over Carol City? Where in the heck is Dr. Phillips? Chaminade? Feels like the list was thrown together to have a Top 25.

Can't wait until we drop our Top 10 rankings for each class...yes Top 10 all classes and there will be a Top 25 which you got to be ranked in the Top 10 to get to. Thinking the SSAC will get a Top 10 as well, but they won't be eligible for the Top 25. We will do our homework and will have some discussion with writers around the state. 

SportsNut25, DarterBlue2, Zoe Boy and 5 others reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Joshua Wilson    684

Joshua Wilson
Posted
24 minutes ago, Joshua Wilson said:

When the fact I see Leon on this list, I know this list is totally suspect. Leon has proven nothing to be Top 25. New coach and they are instantly Top 25?  Seriously, I want to know who put this list together. SMH. Also Northwestern over Carol City? Where in the heck is Dr. Phillips? Chaminade? Feels like the list was thrown together to have a Top 25.

Can't wait until we drop our Top 10 rankings for each class...yes Top 10 all classes and there will be a Top 25 which you got to be ranked in the Top 10 to get to. Thinking the SSAC will get a Top 10 as well, but they won't be eligible for the Top 25. We will do our homework and will have some discussion with writers around the state. 

Forgot to mention....where in the heck is Booker T. Washington at on this list? Are you kidding me? 

MC Rockets, Just A Coach, DarterBlue2 and 2 others reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

ColumbiaHighFan2017class    2,342

ColumbiaHighFan2017class
Posted

List has 0 credibility, a squirrel probably could rank better than FNF did 

 

No Chaminade 

NO Dr Phillips 

No BTW 

 

Yet Leon, Naples and Lee top 25?

 

 

And you got bartram nearly 5 spots higher than mainland who likely gonna put a running clock on them when they play this season

MC Rockets and Zoe Boy reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Zoe Boy    1,016

Zoe Boy
Posted
7 hours ago, Joshua Wilson said:

When the fact I see Leon on this list, I know this list is totally suspect. Leon has proven nothing to be Top 25. New coach and they are instantly Top 25?  Seriously, I want to know who put this list together. SMH. Also Northwestern over Carol City? Where in the heck is Dr. Phillips? Chaminade? Feels like the list was thrown together to have a Top 25.

Can't wait until we drop our Top 10 rankings for each class...yes Top 10 all classes and there will be a Top 25 which you got to be ranked in the Top 10 to get to. Thinking the SSAC will get a Top 10 as well, but they won't be eligible for the Top 25. We will do our homework and will have some discussion with writers around the state. 

I understand why MNW is over Carol City.. A lot of us down here understand why they would rank MNW over Carol City... But that damn district is gonna be serious... 

Floridatech, KeemD321, 954gator and 3 others reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

954gator    480

954gator
Posted
23 hours ago, SportsNut25 said:

Your thoughts? 

  1. STA
  2. Northwestern
  3. Cocoa
  4. AHP
  5. Carol City
  6. Lake Gibson
  7. MIA Central
  8. Jax TCA
  9. Dwyer
  10. Armwood
  11. Southridge
  12. Lakeland
  13. Venice
  14. Plant
  15. Bartram 
  16. Jones
  17. Navarre
  18. Deerfield 
  19. Gables
  20. Gibbons
  21. Mainland
  22. Lee
  23. Naples
  24. Leon
  25. Bishop Moore

I dunno man, this list looks like one of those polls based on the year prior.   Will Lake Gibson be anywhere near as strong without their big QB and that huge OL kid?

Cocoa is a little high IMO.  BT probably a bit too high.  I think it could be much better.

no BTW? 

Zoe Boy, DarterBlue2, KeemD321 and 1 other reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

“PANTHER NATION(CODE BLUE)    920

“PANTHER NATION(CODE BLUE)
Posted
31 minutes ago, Zoe Boy said:

I understand why MNW is over Carol City.. A lot of us down here understand why they would rank MNW over Carol City... But that damn district is gonna be serious... 

The fact that all of those teams are in the same district let alone same division is crazy 

Put one of those team in4a put another 1 of em in 7a STA vs whoever instead of sta having a dam 40+ blowout win margin avg to the state championship almost every year 

 

MNW OR MC VS STA ..that would be a game ... put another 1 in 8a against gables Columbus Deerfield...etc.

MC Rockets reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

ColumbiaHighFan2017class    2,342

ColumbiaHighFan2017class
Posted
12 minutes ago, 954gator said:

I dunno man this list looks more like a how the team was last year poll.   Will Lake Gibson be anywhere near as strong without their big QB and that huge OL kid?

Cocoa is a little high IMO.  BT probably a bit too high.  I think it could be much better.

no BTW? 

If it was last year you would not have bartram or Leon in top 25 though and Dr Phillips and Chaminade would be there 

954gator reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

KeemD321    350

KeemD321
Posted
1 hour ago, 954gator said:

I dunno man this list looks more like a how the team was last year poll.   Will Lake Gibson be anywhere near as strong without their big QB and that huge OL kid?

Cocoa is a little high IMO.  BT probably a bit too high.  I think it could be much better.

no BTW? 

I agree Cocoa is a little too high. I would put them behind AHP, Central, and Carol City. So they would be 6

DarterBlue2 and Zoe Boy reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

DarterBlue2    1,729

DarterBlue2
Posted
32 minutes ago, KeemD321 said:

I agree Cocoa is a little too high. I would put them behind AHP, Central, and Carol City. So they would be 6

Five or six in a top 25, seems about right for Cocoa going into the season. As the season progresses, we will get a better idea where the top 25 stands and who belongs or does not belong in it.

KeemD321 reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

ColumbiaHighFan2017class    2,342

ColumbiaHighFan2017class
Posted

1 STA  (-)  7A

2 Miami Northwestern (-) 6A

3 Miami Central (-)  6A

4 Miami Carol City (-) 6A

5 American Heritage Plantation (-) 5A

6 Chaminade-Madonna  (-) 3A

7 Atlantic Delray (-) 8A

8 Miami Southridge (-) 8A

9 Cocoa (-) 4A

10 Lake Gibson (-) 6A

11 Jax Trinity Christian (-) 5A

12 Apopka (-) 8A

13 Mainland (-) 6A

14 Cardinal Gibbons (-) 5A

15 Miami Booker T Washington (-) 4A

16 Dr Phillips (-) 8A 

17 Miramar (-) 8A

18 Lakeland (-) 7A 

19 Armwood (-) 6A

20 Vero Beach (-) 8A

21 Deerfield Beach (-) 8A

22 Oxbridge Academy (-) 3A

23 Plant (-) 7A

24 Miami Senior (-) 8A

25 Miami Norland (-) 6A

 

 

Here my top 25 for comparison 

 

Which looks better :P

Floridatech reacted to this

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Go To Topic Listing


  • Posts

    • Perspective
      Complaints about Playoffs

      By Perspective · Posted

      There is no perfect system.  But, as you point out, I've never been one of those who says the whole playoff system should be geared up in hopes of have the two "best" teams in each region playing in each of the four regional finals.   There are just way too many factors to make that determination and way too many things happen along the road to a regional final game (upsets being just one of those things).  How many times do the top 2 seeds in a tennis tournament end up matched up against each other in the finals? How often do you see four # 1 seeds make the NCAA Final Four in basketball or hockey?  How often do you see the #1 seed in the AFC and the #1 seed in the NFC square off in the Super Bowl? More often than not, the cream ultimately rises to the top, but I just don't think it's worth the effort in high school football. 
    • badbird
      792 Girls/Boys Basketball Poll #4

      By badbird · Posted

      no I said I was shocked you didn't have them higher.  I would have.  
    • Wavebb
      One/two Good Sport Schools...

      By Wavebb · Posted

      Fort Myers girls basketball: State champs '16, '17 and '18.  Semi-finals '15 and '19.   Softball:  State champs '17 . Semi-finals '18 and '19.    
    • ColumbiaHighFan2017class
      Complaints about Playoffs

      By ColumbiaHighFan2017class · Posted

      And many coaches and AD's have the same feeling and that's why when it was offered last cycle to remove the district champs getting top 4 guaranteed they fought it   But if you feel that way you can't them turn around and say the fhsaa isn't ensuring the best matchups are taking place if you also want the district champs to be guaranteed a top 4 seed, just the reality of it (yes I know you didn't say that specifically yourself, I'm just pointing out the flaw in the line of thinking when people out there try to play both ends of the fence)   Just like many of us knew when the Miami district of death was around that Miami Central, Miami Northwestern and Carol City were the best 3 teams in the entire region but only one would have a seed in the top 4
    • Perspective
      Complaints about Playoffs

      By Perspective · Posted

      I understand your point.   From my perspective, it just shows the fallacy of trying to determine who the "best" teams are before the playoff games have been played.    Again, I see your point, but I'd have a tough time seeding a district runner-up over all the district winners except for one and giving a district runner-up the home-field advantage over all the district winners except for one.  Winning a district ought to count for something and penalizing a district winner (with a lower RPI and, therefor, a seeding worse than a district runner-up) because the other teams in its district had a bad year just doesn't sit right with me. 

  • Who's Online (See full list)

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...